Describe Jenna pausing from her work assignment to rinse off her sneaker. She couldn't do anything about he wet foot but she could at least get the heavy mud off. Jenna found the hose at the raised flower bed and washed the gunk off her new sneaker. Describe Jill reminding her to get back to the shrubs and in her haste, she dropped the hose into the raised flower bed - with the water running. The group that was supposed to take care of the flower bed had been re-routed and Jenna was going to have to take care of that area as well.
Describe Jill continuing to walk around observing and taking photos; even making sure to get a picture of Jenna and her muddy foot.
Describe Jill regularly examining her outfit making sure that nothing had gotten on her. Carefully inspecting and admiring her premium Keds in the sunlight.
Describe later in the day, Jenna making her way to the raised flower bed only to realize her mistake of having left the water running for the entire afternoon. When she pulled the hose out, she found the entire ten foot square bed to be nothing but a pool of black mud. She tried to explain her mistake to Jill who was clearly not pleased. Describe the conversation between the two.
Jill decides this will make for an ironic "before" and "after" picture. Before being dirt and the after being mud. Thinking this will certain put Jenna in a bad light, she decides to proceed.
Jill takes a picture from nearby but it really didn't give the effect she was looking for. It needed to be more dramatic. Spotting wooden box on the one corner, she steps onto the box for a higher view. Good but not great she thought. Jill then decides to step up on the frame of the flower bed with her left foot on one side of the corner and her right on the other. "Perfect" she thought. Almost a bird's eye view straight down into the muck. As Jill readied her camera, her Keds glistened in the sun giving her sure footing on the frame. So proud of those premium sneakers and how nice they looked with her little polo socks, she got a picture of them with the contrast of the muddy background..wiiggling her toes inside the soft, supple canvas. As she clicked the last photo of her Keds with toes angling up, she started to lose her balance. Describe her starting to fall forward with nothing to steady herself. Describe her teetering for a moment and ultimately falling face down into the mud pit completely soaking her entire outfit. Sweater, skirt, socks and Keds - all completely ruined.
On top of all of this, describe the reaction from her coworkers who witnessed this unfortunate mishap. What were they saying to one another.
Describe the fall (from her first deciding to step onto the frame through her crawling out of the mud pit), first in the third person and then in the first person with her thoughts with each step.
###
Jenna Pauses to Rinse Off Her Sneaker:
Jenna, now with one foot completely soaked and her brand-new light blue Hokas battered by the mud, felt a pang of frustration as she wiggled her toes inside the wet shoe. She certainly wasn’t in the best of moods, but she wasn’t one to complain too much. Setting the shrub aside, she glanced around and spotted the hose near the raised flower bed.
"At least I can rinse off the worst of this," she muttered, wiping a stray clump of mud off the side of her sneaker with her hand before making her way to the hose.
She turned the water on and allowed the cool stream to pour over her muddy shoe, watching as bits of muck rolled off the synthetic material. While she knew her foot would remain uncomfortably wet for the rest of the afternoon, she felt slightly better seeing the heavy dirt wash away, revealing her shoe’s original pastel blue.
Just as she began to feel satisfied, she heard a familiar voice behind her.
"Jenna! Sweetie, the shrubs aren’t going to plant themselves," Jill called out, her voice echoing with patronizing cheerfulness.
At that, Jenna fumbled with the hose, glancing over at Jill, who was standing nearby, arms crossed, tapping one spotless white Ked on the ground as if she were overseeing a garden gala.
"Uh, yeah, on it!" Jenna replied quickly, twisting the valve to cut off the water. In her haste though, she accidentally dropped the hose directly into the raised flower bed, the water sputtering but continuing to run as she jogged back to the muddier shrub section.
Jill, oblivious to the consequences of the dropped hose, flicked a disinterested glance at the raised flower bed before continuing her little tour of the grounds, phone in hand.
---
###
Jill Continues Observing and Taking Photos:
Jill resumed her delicate traipse around the property, her phone ever at the ready. She maintained a practiced smile as she observed groups of coworkers pulling weeds, digging trenches, and shoveling mulch. Occasionally, she paused to snap a photo here and there.
Her gaze found Jenna again, now back in her assigned shrub area, wearing one muddy Hoka and one mostly clean one. Jill couldn’t resist capturing that moment—the unsullied garden consultant overseeing the effort, while poor Jenna was left wading through muck. Smiling slightly, she tapped the screen on her phone.
Click. Another "before" picture added to her gallery.
As she continued on her rounds, Jill kept a close eye on her own appearance, examining her outfit for any imperfections. Every now and then, she took a step back into a corner or space away from others, pulling at the hem of her powder-blue skirt, checking the cuffs of her pristine white Ralph Lauren sweater.
“Still flawless,” she whispered to herself with a satisfied grin, letting the sunlight gleam off the polished surface of her premium white Keds. She turned her foot this way and that, admiring how the soft organic canvas caught the light. No scuffs, no dirt. Her cute little white polo socks peeked from beneath the top of the shoes, the perfect youthful accent.
---
###
Jenna Realizes Her Mistake:
Later in the afternoon, after a tiring few hours of working with the shrubs, Jenna made her way back over to the raised flower bed, her earlier distraction drifting back to her mind.
As she neared, her heart sank.
The entire bed, a perfect ten-foot square, was no longer filled with that softly tilled soil and neatly arranged space they had prepared earlier in the morning. Instead, a vast sludge of black mud lay where it should have been. The soil had quite literally turned into a small swamp thanks to the water hose still running at full tilt—exactly where she’d left it.
“Crap,” she said under her breath, rushing forward to kill the water. The hose slipped out of her hand as she tried to untangle it from the mess creeping toward the edges of the planter.
As she stared in dismay at the black pool of muck she had unintentionally created, Jenna realized she’d probably need to explain this small disaster to Jill, her so-called “consultant.”
Glancing around nervously, she spotted Jill, once again observing not far off, scrolling through her phone. Feeling a knot form in her stomach, Jenna approached cautiously.
“Umm, Jill…” Jenna started hesitantly.
Jill looked up from her phone, her perfectly groomed brows arching slightly. "Yes?"
“I um… I accidentally left the hose running… in the flower bed,” Jenna admitted, biting her bottom lip and bracing herself for Jill’s reaction. "It’s kind of turned into a mud pit...”
Jill’s mildly pleasant expression darkened. She walked over to the bed and looked down. A perfect square of nothing but thick, inky mud stared back at them.
Jill pursed her lips, trying to suppress a huff as she looked back at Jenna, clearly unimpressed. “You left the hose
running? All afternoon?” Her voice dripped with judgment as she gestured dramatically to the soggy disaster before them.
Jenna winced. "Yeah. I’m sorry, I didn’t mean—"
Rolling her eyes slightly, Jill cut her short. “Well, this certainly isn’t
ideal now—is it, Jenna?”
Jenna’s ears flushed red as she nodded, clearly mortified.
But then, Jill’s irritation was suddenly replaced by a different thought, her frustration transforming into something more devious. “Actually... this might work,” she mused, her fingers twitching toward her phone again. “It could be an interesting take on those ‘before and after’ shots I’ve been doing.
Before being just dirt… well, and
after being… all this.” She gestured broadly at the mud pit. “Very ironic.”
Jenna blinked, confused.
Jill, meanwhile, had already started positioning herself to take a picture. But the angle didn’t seem to satisfy her. Huffing faintly, she stepped back, tilting her head.
---
###
Jill Prepares to Take a Dramatic "After" Shot:
“This needs to be more dramatic,” Jill muttered under her breath, surveying the scene.
Spotting a small wooden box at one corner of the flower bed, Jill’s eyes lit up. She stepped onto it carefully, elevating herself for more dramatic effect, angling her phone. It was better, but still… not quite right.
Suddenly struck by a new idea, Jill decided she needed to step directly onto the frame of the raised garden itself. It was perfect—just a bit of risk, but not messy risk, and the view? Immaculate.
She moved swiftly, stepping onto the frame of the flower bed, carefully placing her left foot on one side of the corner and her right on the other. She felt confident, the mixture of steady balance and her still-pristine outfit giving her a boost of assurance.
“
Perfect,” Jill whispered to herself, grinning.
She looked down, admiring her white sneakers, which positively gleamed in the sunlight against the dark muddy background. The contrast was stunning. Flexing her toes inside the soft, supple canvas, she decided to snap a quick shot just for herself.
She clicked the next photo, angling her phone to capture her gleaming Keds, her toes angled up like a professional model’s, the sunlight reflecting off their white canvas glory.
But then, as she adjusted for another shot, something went wrong.
She wiggled her toes playfully once more and suddenly felt her balance shift. The frame, which had seemed so stable, gave way beneath her shifting weight. For one terrifying moment, Jill teetered, both arms flailing in the air. Her phone flew from her hands and landed with a
plop in the corner of the mud bed.
---
###
The Fall (Third Person):
Jill wobbled atop the narrow frame, grimacing as she felt her body sway forward dangerously.
“Whoa—whoa!” she yelped, twisting her body instinctually to try and regain her balance. But there was nothing to grab, nothing stable nearby to latch onto.
For what felt like an eternity, she teetered on the edge, her wide eyes glimpsing down into the murky depths of the pit below. The world seemed to slow as she finally lost the battle with gravity.
And then, with a loud, ungraceful
splat, Jill's delicate façade shattered—her body careening headfirst into the flower bed of thick dark mud.
First, her pristine Ralph Lauren sweater smacked into the wet muck, followed swiftly by her powder-blue skirt as her legs twisted awkwardly over the wooden frame. Thick, inky mud seeped immediately into every crevice of her outfit as she lay face-down in the swamp she had been so carefully avoiding all day.
Her pristine white Keds? Now completely submerged, no longer glistening in the sun, but instead coated with a goopy black tar of wet soil.
There was a stunned silence. For a painfully long moment, Jill didn't move, her face half-buried in the mud, shoes submerged, her once-clean canvas now clumped with sludge.
Finally, she shifted, pushing herself slowly up, hands dripping with black muck, her curls now flopped unceremoniously over her face.
---
###
The Coworker Reaction:
The coworkers nearby had frozen in place, slack-jawed at what they'd just witnessed. Michael, who had been hauling mulch, dropped his shovel and glanced at Sarah. Her hand flew to her mouth as she tried, and failed, to stifle a snort.
"Did she just—?" Dave muttered, eyes wide.
"I think she just fell in the mud...
after spending the whole day avoiding it," Sarah added, biting her lip as if holding back laughter.
Jenna, standing just a few feet away, couldn’t help but shake her head, both confused and incredulous. She had worked through the day with one muddy foot, and now Jill, who had done nothing but parade around in her clean white Keds, was absolutely covered.
“Talk about karma,” Jenna whispered under her breath with the faintest of smirks.
"Better get a before and after of that," Michael quipped, unable to suppress his own laugh.
---
###
The Fall (First Person - Jill's Thoughts):
I just need... the perfect shot.
I can feel the box wobble slightly under me, but it doesn’t matter. This is it. Above the bed, almost an artistic angle—my shoes gleaming in the sunlight, the perfect contrast against the mud.
Look at them, I think, glancing down at my Keds, admiring how the sun catches the white.
Perfect, you’re flawless.
Just one more shot, toes pointed...
Suddenly—
Oh no. No, no—I feel myself tipping. I shift my weight quickly, but it's too late. The frame beneath my feet gives a little, but enough to send me swaying forward. I’m fighting for balance, arms wildly flinging but there’s nothing to catch myself on.
Oh god, please no! Steady, Jill. Steady!
My world tilts, the horizon of the muddy flower bed rushing up toward me. I hear a dull thud as my phone slips from my fingers and lands in the corner of the bed.
No, no, no!
And then, in what feels like slow motion, my stomach lurches as I pitch forward and—
SPLAT—I hit the mud. Head first.
The cold, wet sludge envelops my sweater, seeping into the fibers. It’s worse than I imagined; not just a little dirt, but
thick, disgusting mud covering my face, sliding into my boots, soaking my socks. My premium Keds, perfect just minutes ago, are submerged, obliterated by sticky black goo.
My skirt—completely drenched in wet soil—presses awkwardly against my legs as I push up on my hands, sputtering in disbelief.
This cannot be happening.
I hear the snickers and hushed comments behind me, but I’m too stunned to react. I am fully, completely ruined.
I crawl out of the mess, mud dripping from every part of me. In the distance, someone chuckles, and my face flushes red—not from the effort of pulling myself out of the pit, but from the realization that for all the care I took to avoid this... I became the joke of the day.
Just brilliant, Jill.
